The Pro’s & Con’s of the Top 7 Countertop Materials

Whether your planning a kitchen remodel, a bathroom remodel, or just want to add some beautiful custom cabinetry to make a space more functional, you should carefully consider what type of countertop will be used in the space. We’ve put together a list of the top countertop materials our clients request and have highlighted their strengths and weaknesses. Our goal is to help in your planning process for the new year and supply helpful information in caring for your countertops so that you may see them last for years to come!

 

1. Granite

a granite counter top installed in a kitchen remodel in Tiverton, RI

Pros: Extremely durable, heat-resistant, and available in unique natural patterns.
Cons: Requires periodic sealing to resist stains, can chip if struck by a heavy object, and may be on the pricier side.
Tip: Reseal your granite once a year to maintain its stain resistance. Between sealings, use mild, pH-neutral cleaners and wipe up acidic spills (like citrus juice) promptly to avoid dull spots.

2. Quartzite

Quartzite countertop in color: Fantasy brown installed in a kitchen remodel in East Greenwich, RI

Pros: Extremely durable, heat-resistant, and scratch-resistant; beautiful, unique patterns; adds value to property.
Cons: Expensive, requires sealing, can chip or crack, and may be porous if not maintained properly.
Tip: Regularly seal quartzite surfaces with a high-quality stone sealer every 1-2 years, or as needed, to prevent staining and damage. Promptly clean spills, especially acidic ones like lemon juice or vinegar, to avoid long-term harm.

3. Marble

Kitchen remodel by Red House Design Build Providence RI
Carrara Bianco Premium Marble Honed in a kitchen remodel on the East Side of Providence, RI

Pros: Classic beauty, cool surface ideal for baking, and unique veining patterns.
Cons: Easily etched by acids, prone to staining, and needs regular care.
Tip: Seal your marble at least twice a year and clean spills immediately—especially anything acidic like vinegar or wine. Consider keeping a spray bottle of a gentle, stone-specific cleaner handy.

4. Butcher Block

Historic kitchen remodel on the East Side of Providence
A walnut butcher block adds warmth to a bright kitchen on the East Side of Providence, RI

Pros: Warm, natural appearance and can be renewed by sanding out scratches or marks.
Cons: Sensitive to water and heat, needs regular oiling to prevent drying and cracking.
Tip: Apply a food-safe mineral oil or beeswax finish monthly to maintain moisture balance. Keep damp dishcloths and hot pans off the surface to prevent warping or burn marks.

6. Quartz

kitchen island home renovation first floor
White quartz for this beautiful kitchen remodel in Tiverton, RI

Pros: Non-porous, low-maintenance, and consistent in appearance with excellent scratch resistance.
Cons: Not as heat-tolerant as natural stone and can be more expensive.
Tip: Always use trivets or hot pads under pots and pans. Quartz’s resin binders can discolor or warp under direct, prolonged heat, so a little precaution goes a long way.

Pros: Durable, customizable, and can achieve a sleek, modern or industrial look.
Cons: Can crack over time, requires sealing, and is quite heavy.
Tip: Reapply a high-quality concrete sealer every 1-3 years. In day-to-day use, wipe up spills and avoid acidic cleaners that can degrade the sealant.

7. Soapstone

A gorgeous black soapstone adds contrast to this historic kitchen

Pros: Non-porous, stain-resistant, and develops a natural patina that some homeowners love.
Cons: Softer surface prone to scratches and dings, limited color range.
Tip: Rubbing mineral oil into the surface every few months helps even out the patina and makes minor scratches blend in, reducing the need for sanding or refinishing.

  • Category :
  • Type :